Lodha bowls a googly at BCCI
It was the day after the storm. They gathered at a fancy five-star resort for what was purported to be a glittering night time, in honour of the most effective of Indian cricket stars. The annual BCCI Awards occasion to acknowledge the superlative performances on the pitch supplied an excuse to the brass of world’s most
It was the day after the storm. They gathered at a fancy five-star resort for what was purported to be a glittering night time, in honour of the most effective of Indian cricket stars. The annual BCCI Awards occasion to acknowledge the superlative performances on the pitch supplied an excuse to the brass of world’s strongest cricket board to make one other business-class journey to Mumbai and pat their very own backs. Solely on that night time, January 5, the swagger was lacking, changed as a substitute by hushed voices. A way of intrigue hung within the air. The Justice Lodha Fee, constituted by the Supreme Courtroom to do a clean-up of the rot within the nation’s cricket administration, had submitted its suggestions, which geared toward altering the construction and spirit of the BCCI without end. The riddle troubling everybody within the corridor was: what subsequent?
Whereas there have been many hiccups within the BCCI’s 87-year-old historical past, this one is sure to be probably the most troublesome and significant, questioning and difficult the very existence of the world’s richest cricket physique. Sixty six-year-old R. M. Lodha, the previous chief justice of India, had on January four delivered what appeared like a knockout punch to an already-dazed BCCI: form up or ship out. For that he additionally prescribed the recipe, stopping in need of taking their most-prized possession, the autonomy, however taking away all their badges. And if the Supreme Courtroom bench, headed by Justice T.S. Thakur had been to make the suggestions binding on the BCCI, it could herald a chapter hitherto unseen and unimagined in Indian cricket.
Unimagined as a result of not so way back, the cosy membership had been pulling the suitable strings. The IPL, barring a minor skirmish right here and there, was rolling out younger expertise and minting cash too. N. Srinivasan, as BCCI chief held the flock collectively and with gamers pension and one-time bonus funds being handed to former worldwide and home gamers, the case examine was worthy of all of the applause. However then, he acquired entangled within the spot fixing story that broke in Might 2013. When his son-in-law Gurunath Meiyappan was caught by Mumbai Police for betting and suspected spot-fixing, Srinivasan made his greatest mistake by selecting to look the opposite means. If solely he had acted as BCCI Chief and penalised the Chennai Tremendous Kings below the IPL Code of Conduct, the sport of cricket would have remained with them. As soon as the spot-fixing rip-off was taken to courtroom, the Supreme Courtroom did the clean-up act by way of Mudgal Fee. The following step was fixing the rot on the source-the BCCI.
A BCCI outdated timer places it in cricketing parlance. “BCCI, caught Srinivasan, bowled Lodha,” he advised India Right now, “Srinivasan ought to have learn the warning indicators way back. If solely he hadn’t proven conceitedness in the direction of the authorized system when incidents of spot-fixing got here to mild in 2013, we would not have seen this present day. He saved pushing the objective submit to retain his energy and now we’re on the mercy of the Supreme Courtroom.”
Does BCCI actually need this shock remedy? There are two methods of wanting on the glass. With out their effectivity and imaginative and prescient within the1980s and 1990s, the BCCI wouldn’t have been the most effective in enterprise. The cash and clout raised not simply the stakes for BCCI, it additionally upped the usual of cricket within the nation. However the monetary success and the appearance of the money-spinning IPL in all probability distracted the board from its core business-cricket. Suffering from a number of controversies and the autocratic tenure of Srinivasan, the BCCI, within the final three years, needed to spend extra money and time within the courts than maybe within the promotion of the gentleman’s sport.
Though it has put up a courageous face for now saying “we’ll speak after we totally examine the report,” the board is totally conscious of the implications. On the Mumbai occasion, BCCI President Shashank Manohar, a authorized luminary in his personal proper, was closeted with senior workplace bearers. A Particular Basic Physique assembly will probably be known as soon-a 15-day discover should be given first to state associations. They may even ship the report back to state associations, asking them to make notes after which kind a committee to debate its scope and viability. Manohar is aware of that if the BCCI had been to concede territory to the Lodha report, its clout in world cricket would undergo.
The board is not going to have a lot discomfort in accepting the milder modifications resembling delinking the IPL from BCCI, agreeing to the formation of an Apex Council of 9 members and getting a CEO to manage and management its funds. It’ll haven’t any qualms in supporting a regulation to legalise betting or permitting creation of a gamers affiliation. However the board is more likely to combat with all its assets to guard itself from these six directives of Lodha: carry the BCCI below the ambit of RTI, one-state one-vote, one-post one-man, office-bearers retire on the age of 70, restrict the phrases of office-bearers and bar ministers and authorities servants from holding positions in BCCI.
The predicament for BCCI is that it will possibly neither reject all of the recommendations-they agreed in totality to Justice Lodha’s suggestions final yr and suspended CSK and Rajasthan Royals from the IPL-nor will or not it’s ready to cherry-pick suggestions. It might finally boil right down to all or nothing, not a straightforward battle contemplating Lodha’s authorized pedigree.
Nattily dressed and flanked by fellow panel members, Justice (Retd) Ashok Bhan and Justice (Retd) R V Raveendran, Lodha selected his phrases fastidiously whereas addressing the media. “All this may not have been essential if we had gone in for a quick-fix resolution and handed the management of BCCI to the federal government. We needed to retain the autonomy of BCCI and the hardest problem for us was that there have been illnesses which wanted a remedy.” BCCI mandarins did not have to had been to learn between traces as Lodha minced no phrases.
By no means averse to calling a spade a spade, Lodha headed the bench that monitored the CBI probe into the coal blocks allocation rip-off, cancelling all of the 214 allotments since 1993. It was throughout Coalgate that he famously referred to CBI as “a caged parrot”. So, it is going to be troublesome to disregard his phrases when he says, “Cricket must be saved and I’ll be certain that the followers aren’t dissatisfied. I’ll do the most effective to herald transparency and accountability.”
Whereas cricket followers would need the sport to be cleansed, no one needs India’s hottest sport to be managed by the federal government. Not like different sporting federations, the BCCI is the one one unbiased of presidency management. Moreover large bucks-India nonetheless creates about 70 per cent of the world’s cricketing income. “Do they need us to satisfy the identical destiny as hockey or soccer federations, which want authorities sanctions to ship nationwide groups to competitions?” a former BCCI president requested. Ajay Shirke, president of Maharashtra Cricket Affiliation, who stop as BCCI treasurer in protest towards Srinivasan’s dealing with of the spot-fixing controversy, questions the effectiveness of one-state one-vote method. For example, Maharashtra and Gujarat have three associations every. “So which considered one of these three associations in Maharashtra-Mumbai , Maharashtra and Vidarbha-will get the one vote? How will you all of a sudden convert an 80-year outdated affiliation into an affiliate member?”
Mumbai Cricket Affiliation, backed by NCP chief Sharad Pawar, whose private ambition of regaining management of BCCI will probably be thwarted by the higher age restrict of 70 years, has already known as an emergency assembly on January 13. That could possibly be the primary amongst a number of such conferences to be held in varied corners of the nation. For now, BCCI and its state associates appear to have most well-liked to duck the “bodyline” bouncer from Justice Lodha. However, as they are saying, the final ball has not been bowled but and this sport will definitely go right down to the wire.
Comply with the author on Twitter@VikrantGupta73